AustenBlog...she's everywhere

21 April 2008

Losing the thread

Filed under: Jane in the News, Miss Austen Regrets — Mags @ 2:48 am

This article is probably not unexpected, with the impending broadcast of Miss Austen Regrets on UK television, but we found it a trifle strange nonetheless.

She flirts remorselessly. She wakes up with a hangover. She wisecracks with her women friends about the myriad failings of the pitiful male specimens she surveys. Sex and the City’s Samantha? Carrie? Miranda? No, Jane Austen, of course.

OHDEARJANENOTWITHTHESEXANDTHECITYCOMPARISONSAGAIN!!!!! Elvis wept, people! Something original, please!

“Your only way to get a man like Mr Darcy is to make him up,” says Olivia Williams’ Jane Austen to her niece Fanny (a sentiment echoed by my mother, who once sent me a card bearing the cheery greeting “Searching for Mr Right?” and then inside the helpful solution: “Look in fiction!”). This vehement assertion of no-nonsense realism is underlined by an obsession with money that has this Jane swinging slightly wildly between acerbic social commentator and Regency Heather Mills.

Oh, she has GOT to be kidding us. The “obsession” with money in the film was related to the fact that the Austens, as a family, had suffered several financial setbacks–setbacks, incidentally, that may have contributed to Jane Austen’s death (severe emotional distress exacerbates the symptoms of Addison’s disease). They didn’t even put them all in the film–we can’t remember the expected legacy from Uncle Leigh Perrot not coming through, but that happened around the same time that Henry’s bank failed, if memory serves. Jane was at the time in her career when she was just starting to make some decent money, and get attention in the right places–reviews by Walter Scott, the patronage of the Prince Regent–and then she fell ill, and couldn’t take advantage of it. Are we the only ones who can follow a very logical plot? Sheesh!

Besides, Heather Mills, unlike Jane Austen, can actually go out and get a job. Not that she will, but just saying.

It is, however, somewhat undercut by the drama’s central thesis: that Jane Austen was a passionate romantic, one who withdrew her acceptance of a rich young Londoner’s proposal because she wasn’t in love with him, and who regretted, till her dying day, her decision not to marry the man she loved because he was too poor.

We think she has Miss Austen Regrets confused with Becoming Jane. Surely she didn’t think that Jane regretted Brook Bridges? (In the movie, meaning–it’s doubtful she spared the guy a thought in real life).

Frankly, this whole thing sounds like it was written by Bridget Jones after a bottle of Chardonnay, except that we know Bridget suffers from writers’ block. By the end we were wondering WTFerrars it had to do with Jane Austen.

2 Responses to “Losing the thread”

  1. Karenlee Says:

    Heh heh… it could have been worse Mags. They could have said Victorian Heather Mills. And using the word “obsession” with money in connection with her name gives completely the wrong ‘more, more, more’ spin to it. If they were obsessed with anything, it was the idea of whether or nto they were going to be able to keep a roof over their head. The first references in Jane’s letters to feeling unwell were in Spring 1816. It was March 15th of that year that Henry’s back failed. That emotional and psychological blow could well have even triggered her first symptoms. Her health was up and down over the next year. She herself thought she was rallying when there was the horrible disappointment of the legacy at the end of March 1817. One month later she wrote her will. The only descriptive phrase of Austen I can really agree with 100% is “no-nonsense realism”. That’s Jane :)

  2. Cinthia Says:

    BTW the broadcast has been officially conffirmed by BBC (at last!) in the schedule already mentioned by press sources (April 27th, 20:00 to 21:30 GMT, BBC1):

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/pressoffice/proginfo/tv/wk18/sun.shtml#sun_austen (BBC Press Office schedule)

    http://www.bbc.co.uk/drama/missaustenregrets/ (BBC official page)

    An almost suitable day since Jane Austen’s will was dated April 27th.

 

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License