The Complete Jane Austen News Roundup: No News To Round Up Edition
After all the excitement and media attention of the first few weeks, perhaps, as the sole Mansfield Park 08 review we found (actually Alert Janeite Lisa sent it to us) says, we have reached adaptation fatigue with Jane Austen.
It’s hard not to wonder, three weeks in, if PBS’ decision to air “The Complete Jane Austen” in single-episode weekly installments does a disservice to its subject. As early scenes of “Mansfield Park” unfold there is no denying that the bloom has faded a bit from the rose. The manor houses, the décolletage, the inevitable brass candlesticks do not provide quite the cozy respite they once did. The characters too seem a bit worn about the edges: Here is the spirited but disenfranchised heroine, the noble man she loves but seemingly cannot have, the scheming female friend, the charming rake, all vying for income and position with marriage based in love being the ultimate and elusive prize.
So one can be forgiven a little armchair psychoanalysis — is a country walk in Austen ever just a country walk? And why are all the rakes and rogues instantly identifiable by the wildness of their hair?
But it would be a shame to take what may be a flaw in the concept out on its parts. As itself, “Mansfield Park” is as charming an adaptation of the novel as one would wish, and if American television viewers can find value in weekly weigh-ins of the morbidly obese or soap operas thinly disguised by surgical scrubs, they can certainly look past the repetition of skirt-trailing picnics and thundering carriages bringing dire messages in the middle of the night.
Hear, hear! And it’s awfully early in the Complete Jane Austen to be getting bored with it, especially with Miss Austen Regrets and a new S&S, both of which have received very positive reviews, on the way still. While MP is not perhaps the most inspiring film in the current set, taking a glass-half-full attitude, we are looking forward to seeing James D’Arcy in Gaping Frilly Shirtage™ (one of his best looks in our opinion), not to mention Sir Walter Elliot’s brocade suit from P95.


Who says we’re dried-up tar-hearted spinster purists, anyway?
The PBS Remotely Connected blog has posted the guest blogger reviews for Mansfield Park. Lori Smith also concentrates on the positive.
So, the great triumph of this adaptation, to me, was that I actually liked it, and I liked Fanny. The screenwriter took liberties to make her run around, flirt a bit, smile all the time. Her energy makes her more attractive. They managed to do that without sacrificing any of her goodness, which is crucial.
The way the Lover’s Vows scenes were handled helped me understand why it would have been so scandalous, which made the whole book make more sense. If it’s a very shortened story, you get the sense that pug-loving Lady Bertram is ridiculous for her indolence, that Edmund is kind and conscientious, if tempted, and that the Crawfords are charmingly deceitful.
Diane K. Danielson insists she’s “not a purist.” Back there again, are we?
Alert Janeite Lisa also sent an article about the composer of the soundtrack for Miss Austen Regrets.
Based on the life and letters of Jane Austen, “Miss Austen Regrets” tells the story of the novelist’s final years. The drama provides an insight into Austen’s own romantic life, examining why, despite setting the standard for romantic fiction, she died having never married or met her own Mr Darcy.
Ugh. It’s hard to get a grip on this one; some things seem so good, and some seem so…ugh.













January 26th, 2008 at 11:25 am
I know I’m late with these, but I haven’t been able to watch them on Sundays. They showed Northanger Abbey last night. I was happy to find myself enjoying it. It did seem rushed and wondered how much of the rush was from the cuts made for PBS or was inherent in the adaptation, but now I want to read the book again. Does anyone know if the “imagination” sequences carried on through out the movie in its uncut format? They were wonderfully over the top, but they disappeared in the last 2/3 of the film. I don’t know if I’m going to make it through MP. From the previews, I am unconvinced by the actress playing Fanny. Maybe they can show me otherwise that she is a good Fanny, but I have my doubts. But maybe I’ll have to watch it just to see Mr. Eliot’s suit. That thing is so beautiful. Every time I watch that I tell myself that I need to get one just like it.
January 26th, 2008 at 11:51 am
Good news on MP.
It’s very light, but it has some very good points. I particulalrly love the family resemblances in the Bertrams. Fanny is so physically different from all of them- she’s a real oddbod- until we meet William, and then suddenly, she makes perfect sense. A good piece of casting, there.
I’m not saying any more until after it’s shown on PBS- it wouldn’t be fair.
January 26th, 2008 at 12:23 pm
Isn’t that funny about the brocade suit! I’d never noticed it in MP before! It’s my absolute favorite Sir Walter outfit and one of the many things that makes Corin Redgrave the ultimate Sir Walter imo.
Whenever I’ve watched that scene with my father he loves to blurt out “he’s wearing the curtains!” So I showed him the likeness in the two suits and had to chuckle when he commented “Someone else must have thought that suit looked like curtains as well and wasn’t the leftover cloth from play at Mansfield used to make curtains at the parsonage?”
And just the thought of James D’Arcy in that wonderful frilly sirtage! *swoon*
January 26th, 2008 at 7:23 pm
As far as I am concerned, MP was the least objectionable of the ITV productions. And James D’Aarcy’s frilly shirtage had nothing to do with it…
January 27th, 2008 at 3:25 am
Hey, I thought that Sir Walter borrowed that brocade suit from the Von Trapp kids! Looks like the same curtains to me.
January 27th, 2008 at 6:51 am
I love that second picture, when aghasted comprehension is just starting to spread across their faces. They also look rather silly in those costumes, emphasizing Edmund’s comments: “Yes, to see real acting, [good hardened real acting; but I would hardly walk from this room to the next to look at the raw efforts of those who have not been bred to the trade,–a set of gentlemen and ladies, who have all the disadvantages of education and decorum to struggle through.”