(We’re working on our review, we swear!)
Lots and lots of reviews rolling in for The Jane Austen Book Club; it’s at 61% at Rotten Tomatoes, and we especially liked this bit from Michelle Orange’s review at The Reeler.
Time was clearly taken here to do better than fine with material that had a sizeable no-brainer audience built right into the title.
Thank you. THANK YOU. With all the new adaptations and films we’ve snarked in the four three years of this blog, our main complaint has been the complete disregard for the sensibilities of the main audience for such adaptations–Janeites. And the thing is, are our sensibilities that much different from the rest of the world’s? We don’t really think so; and what’s wrong with challenging the public to stretch a little? Director Robin Swicord even noticed a renewed interest in Austen among her cast.
Still, when Swicord tried to get her cast into the spirit by hosting a book club meeting to discuss “Emma,” she was a little surprised at the response.
“Maggie Grace was the only one who’d done her homework,” Swicord said, citing the actress who plays book clubber Allegra. “Everyone else had pulled stuff off the Internet. But as we talked, people began to say, ‘I wish I’d read the book.’ It was so funny to watch their interest in Austen ignite.”
Uh huh. And even still,
But Swicord was clear on her desire not to take “a strong intellectual approach.”
And the film doesn’t, not really; the discussion by the book club is average, like any group of reasonably intelligent people reading good books might have, with differences of opinion and built-in prejudices (and, referring back to the first article we linked, “competitive hosting and eating.” Oh yes).
“There are some people who are very dedicated to the cult of Jane,” Swicord said. “I appreciate those people enormously, and I am a hair’s breadth away from that myself.” Swicord invited some of them — members of the Jane Austen Society of North America, a group Swicord has been tempted to join — to the “Book Club” set.
hee hee. Wait till Vancouver, Robin. We are JASNA. You will be assimilated. Resistance is futile.
The Hollywood Reporter also has an article about Ms. Swicord’s journey in bringing the novel to the screen, which includes, among other things, the fascinating information that the editor’s name is Maryann Brandon. She makes it seem all “I picked her because of her great work on Alias” but we Janeites know the truth! She also talked to All Things Considered.
Roger Ebert liked it, unsurprisingly, as he is an F.O.J., despite his troubling affection for MP99. (more…)