Alert Janeites Lisa and Cathy sent us a link to an article in the Telegraph with more information about So Odd a Mixture, the book that claims several characters in Pride and Prejudice suffer from various psychological conditions. We’ve already had quite a discussion on this book in the previous post about it.
Phyllis Ferguson Bottomer, a speech pathologist in Canada, analyses eight characters from Austen’s classic novel, in a book that teachers are being encouraged to use to liven up GCSE English lessons.
She argues that five characters from the Bennet family, and three from the Fitzwilliam clan, have fundamental difficulties with communication and empathy. It provides an explanation for some characters’ awkward behaviour at crowded balls, their frequent silences or the tendency to lapse into monologues rather than truly converse with others, she said.
Mr Darcy’s “unaccountable rudeness” can be blamed on “high-functioning autism or Asperger’s syndrome”, which Austen wrote about without knowing what it was, it is claimed.
In her book, So Odd a Mixture, Miss Bottomer quotes Austen’s description of Mr Collins - “awkward and solemn, apologising instead of attending, and often moving wrong without being aware of it”.
The author says it epitomises “some of the co-ordination problems those on the autistic spectrum can have”. Mr and Mrs Bennet, the squabbling couple, are also said to be sufferers. Lydia, the heroine’s younger sister, is also described as having attention deficit disorder after she runs off with Mr Wickham.
However, the campaign to use the book for GCSEs seems to have hit a bit of a snag.
The book, which the publishers hope will be used to provoke debate in schools, was dismissed by the National Association for the Teaching of English as “wonderfully absurd”.
Oops!