The Myth of the Demure Jane Austen
Back there again, are we? According to a review of a book on modesty in modern women:
The growing interest in rigid social strictures manifested by the Jane Austen craze tells her that young women are pining for interference as their mothers once pined for liberation, even to the extent of wanting to be nagged and called on the carpet.
Oh, yes. The “Jane Austen craze” doesn’t have anything to do with just plain good stories that speak to women and men from all over the world and all walks of life. We just read them and write about them and spend an hour or more a night posting on this blog about them because we secretly want someone to tell us how to live our life. We haven’t learned anything from reading Jane Austen’s novels, mind, such as learning to trust our own judgment or not to rely on appearances or to think carefully about our actions. We’re just passive receptacles to be pushed this way and that by stronger minds; just like that sweet, demure young lady, Elizabeth Bennet, who wouldn’t dream of decidedly expressing her opinion to someone older and of a higher station, or telling a gentleman precisely what he can do with his very obliging proposal of marriage. Such a nice quiet girl that Lizzy is! And being a rather pretty girl, she’s lucky that Darcy didn’t just ravish her, because she was asking for it, you know.
Tread carefully, writers, when you attempt to co-opt Jane Austen for your own ends, and remember: she does not work for you. Now shoo, before we get out the Cluebat of Janeite Righteousness and start pushing you around.












