Two articles on the same website discuss the return of the Empire waist in the latest fashions; interestingly, the writers have opposite opinions on its suitability, though both articles invoke the name of Jane, and with good reason, as the empire waist dress was in style during the period that all her books were published, so we are accustomed to seeing and imagining her heroines wearing such gowns.
The first apparently agrees with Joe Wright, the director of P&P3, who said that empire waist dresses make women look like “marshmallows.”
Still, it’s not a look I would wear today, even though you’ll see empire tops and dresses in all the shops right now (a reflection of our current ’60s fascination, says Style.com).
And if I needed any reminding why it’s a silhouette only a few women can wear, I had to look no farther than the 59th Cannes Film Festival last month.
At least eight actresses crossed the red carpet in dresses that cascaded from the bust, and all but a couple looked - to put it kindly - pregnant.
[. . .]
Now, most women I know don’t want to wear clothes that add pounds. Most of these actresses are rake-thin.
And most of them still looked fat.
Think twice before you buy an empire dress - unless, of course, you are pregnant. In that case, it makes total sense for the times.
Actually, it depends upon the cut of the dress. If it is full and gathered in the front, and the wearer has poor posture as so many young celebrities seem to these days, yes, you will look pregnant. The second article has something else to say.
In fact, the empire shape is one of the most flattering known to women. It frames the face and flatters the breasts and decollete. And these are the parts that are easiest to enhance. All you need is makeup and a good bra (which Miranda Richardson was clearly lacking at Cannes).
Moreover, worn properly, the empire hides the parts that are most difficult to mask - the flabby belly, jiggly thighs, big bum.
Get it cut on the bias in a flowy fabric without gathers in the front and you’re golden. And make sure it fits! That’s ninety percent of the problem that celebrities have when they look stupid in an outfit–because it doesn’t fit.